Date: Sunday, October 23, 2011, 12:42 AM
From: ramanujam kishore
Subject: Fw: Chennai from 1883 to 1939
-------------------------------------------
WE SHOULD PRESERVE THIS
MEENAKSHISUNDARAM
3.4.12
Fw: Chennai from 1883 to 1939 01.09.2011
Date: Sunday, October 23, 2011, 12:42 AM
From: ramanujam kishore
Subject: Fw: Chennai from 1883 to 1939
-------------------------------------------
WE SHOULD PRESERVE THIS
MEENAKSHISUNDARAM
3.1.12
Recent Posts - 01.09.2011
----------------------------------------------------------------------
CWP No.16346 of 2010.
THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
*****
CWP No.16346 of 2010
Date of Decision: 09.11.2012
*****
Madan Lal Gandhi and others
. . . .Petitioners
Versus
Union of India and others
. . . . Respondents
*****
CORAM: HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE A.K. SIKRI, CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE RAKESH KUMAR JAIN
*****
Present: Ms.Alka Chatrath, Advocate,
for the petitioners.
Mr.Tarun Singla, Advocate,
for respondent No.1.
Mr.B.R. Mahajan, Advocate,
for respondents No.2 to 4.
*****
RAKESH KUMAR JAIN, J.
The petitioners are all retired Class I officers of Life
Insurance Corporation of India (for short ‘the Corporation’),
who have challenged the discrimination against employees
retired between 1.1.1986 and 1.8.1997 while framing Rules
with regard to grant of Dearness Relief to pensioners at par
with in-service employees, up-gradation of pension and have
prayed for issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari for
quashing order dated 3.6.2010 rejecting the claim of the
petitioners for removal of anomaly in the matter of rate of
Dearness Relief to the pensioners and Dearness Allowance to
serving employees on the same amount of pension/salary and
up-gradation of pension on pay revision and further prayed for
issuance of writ in the nature of mandamus to implement the
decision passed by the Corporation in its meeting of the Board
of Directors dated 24.11.2001 and also for issuance of
direction by way of mandamus for striking down the words “as
on 1.8.1997” in clause (3) of Section 1 “Short title,
commencement and application” in the notification dated
22.6.2000 and words “as on 1.8.2002” in Notification dated
5.9.2005 with consequential effects and for issuance of
direction to fix pension of the petitioners as per the substituted
scales of pay equivalent to the stage applicable to them in the
scrapped pay scale as on the date of their retirement and pay,
pension at the rate of 50% of such basic pay as arrived at on
and from 1.8.1997 and thereafter on and from 1.8.2002 with
all consequential benefits with 12% interest.
The petitioners have given a note in the index of the
writ petition that a similar case i.e. CWP No.654 of 2007 titled
as Krishna Murari Lal Asthana Vs. LIC of India and others was
allowed by the Rajasthan High Court directing the
respondent-Corporation to take a decision for implementation
of the Resolution dated 24.11.2001 passed by the Board
holding that the Corporation cannot provide different criteria
for grant of Dearness Allowance to the existing pensioners
based on cut off date i.e. 31.7.1997 and as such, the benefit
arising out of the directions above would, however, be
considered by the Corporation so that every retired employee
may get the same benefit.
The text of the directions of the order in CWP
No.654 of 2007 titled as Krishna Murari Lal Asthana Vs.
LIC of India and others decided on 12.1.2010 by the Single
Judge of the Rajasthan High Court, attached as Annexure P-20
with the writ petition, is as under:
“In the facts and circumstances of
the case, I am of the view that
resolution passed by the Board of
LIC does not need approval of the
Central Government thus the
Corporation may give effect to its
resolution dated 24.11.2001 to
avoid discrimination amongst
existing pensioners.
In light of the discussion made
above, both the writ petitions are
allowed. The respondent
Corporation is directed to take a
decision for implementation of the
resolution dated 24.11.2011
passed by the Board. The
respondent Corporation cannot
provide different criteria for grant
of dearness allowance to the
existing pensioners based on cut
off date i.e. 31.7.1997. The benefit
arising out of the directions above
would, however, be considered by
the respondent corporation so that
every retired employee may get the
same benefit. Costs made easy.”
Learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted
that the case of the petitioners is covered by the aforesaid
judgment which has been further upheld by the Division
Bench of the Rajasthan High Court in D.B. Special Appeal
(Writ) No.494 of 2010 titled as Life Insurance Corporation
of India Vs. Krishna Murari Lal Asthana and others
decided on 21.1.2011, with the following observations:
“We are of the view that whatever
grievance with regard to the
implementation of the Board’s
resolution dated 24.11.2001 is
concerned, the same can be raised
by the Union of India who has
chosen not to file any appeal in the
matter and this can easily be
considered as an approval of the
said resolution of the Board dated
24.11.2001 which was allegedly
pending for nine years. The Board
of LIC, who is the appellant before
us against the judgment of the
learned Single Judge, had itself
taken a decision to remove the
disparities and the discrimination
with regard to the payment of
Dearness Allowance and pension
to the retired employees under its
resolution of the Board dt.
24.11.2001, which was in public
interest. It could not and should
not have filed the present appeal
against the judgment of the
learned Single Judge as the
learned Single Judge has provided
an umbrella to the appellant for the
implementation of the decision of
the Board dt. 24.11.2001 on the
categorical statement made by the
learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the Union of India and
not assailed in appeal by the
Union of India.
In the light of the submissions
made by the learned counsel for
the Union of India before the
learned Single Judge, we find that
these appeals filed by the L.I.C. of
India have no merit and the same
stand dismissed.”
Although counsel for the Corporation has
submitted that SLP has been preferred against the aforesaid
order of the Division Bench but its operation has not been
stayed by the Apex Court.
After hearing learned counsel for the parties, we are
of the considered opinion that since it is not in dispute that
similar relief prayed for by the petitioners has been granted by
the learned Single Judge of the Rajasthan High Court in the
case of Krishna Murari Lal Asthana (Supra) which has been
maintained in appeal and the petitioners are satisfied with the
same order, the present writ petition is thus, allowed, in terms
of the order passed in the aforesaid case namely Krishna
Murari Lal Asthana (Supra).
(A.K. SIKRI) (RAKESH KUMAR JAIN)
CHIEF JUSTICE JUDGE
NOVEMBER 09, 2012
Vivek
-----------------------------------------------------------------
PENSION REVISION WRIT PETITIONS AT CHANDIGARHMonday, November 19, 2012 8:57 PM
From: "asthana_jaipur ASTHANA"
I HAVE JUST COME TO KNOW FROM SHRI SN CHHABRA
THAT THE WRIT PETITIONS FILED IN CHANDIGARH HC
HAVE BEEN ALLOWED ON 9TH OF THIS MONTH ON THE
BASIS OF THE JUDGMENT IN THE CASE OF KRISHNA
MURARI LAL ASTHANA VS UOI AND OTHERS.
THE SAME RELIEFS HAVE BEEN GRANTED.
I AM AWAITING A COPY OF THE JUDGMENT
WHEN I WILL SEND YOU THE DETAILS THEREOF
THIS IS FOR YOUR INFORMATION PLEASE
------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------
To: Seetha And Kishore
Sent: Tuesday, October 30, 2012 12:23 AM
PL PUT THE FOLLOWING MESSAGE ON THE BLOG FOR INFORMATION OF ALL CONCERNED KML ASTHANA
DEAR ALL
I AM GETTING INFORMATIONS FROM SOME QUARTERS
THAT SOME UNION/ASSOCIATIONS ARE PLANNING TO
MAKE APPLICATION FOR IMPLEADMENT IN OUR SLP.
THESE PERSONS EITHER INDIVIDUALLY OR AS OFFICE
BEARERS OF SOME ASSOCIATION ARE APPARENTLY AND VIVIDLY PLAYING IN THE HANDS OF MANAGEMENT AND ARE OUT TO DELAY THE RESULT OF SLP ONE WAY OR THE OTHER. WHILE I EXPECT TOGET THE SLP DECIDED WITHIN TWO THREE MONTHS ANY SUCH MOVE ON THEIR PART SHOULD IT COME WILL DELAY THE DECISION AT LEAST BY THREE FOUR YEARS AND THAT IS THE DESIRE OF THE MANAGEMENT TO SOMEHOW FRUSTRATE OUR MOVE IN THE BATTLE WHICH THEY HAVE ALMOST LOST.
PL BEWARE AND OPPOSE ANY SUCH MOVE WHICH IS DESCTRUCTIVE AND ADVERSE TO THE WELL BEING OF LIC PENSIONERS. OTHERWISE IT IS NOT UNDERSTANDABLE AS TO WHAT PURPOSE THEY WANT TO GAIN BY THIS MOVE BECAUSE ONCE WE WIN IN THE SLP THE BENEFIT WILL BE PAYABLE TO ONE AND ALL THROUGH OUT THE LENGTH AND BREADTH OF THE COUNTRY, FOR THEY SHOULD REMEMBER THE GRATUITY CASE AS ALSO THE PRINCIPLE OF LAW THAT ONE REGULATION CANNOT BE APPLIED DIFFERENTLY TO DIFFERENT PERSONS.
MAY GOD GIVE THEM BETTER COUNSEL THAT THEY SHOULD NOT DELAY OUR COURSE OF VICTORY WHICH IS FOR ONE AND ALL.
KML ASTHANA
--------------------------------------------------------------
23.10.2012. SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Jaipur Cases : S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 6676 of 1998 &S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 654 of 2007 - 03.09.2011
30.08.2012.
No. COURT REGARDING DATE JUDGEMENT ( Please see 'Attachment' for full Judgement) REMARKS CASE NO YEAR PETITIONERS RESPONDENTS
1 RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT - JAIPUR BENCH D.A.Neutralisation 12th January, 2010 both the writ petitions are allowed.(LIC files appeal) The respondent Corporation is directed to take a decision for implementation of the resolution dated 24.11.2001 passed by the Board. The respondent Corporation cannot provide different criteria for grant of dearness allowance to the existing pensioners based on cut off date i.e. 31.7.1997. The benefit arising out of the directions above would, however, be considered by the respondent Corporation so that every retired employee may get the same benefit. Costs made easy. Civil Writ Petition 6676(+654) 1998 Krishna Murari Lal Asthana Union of India & Ors.
2 RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT - JAIPUR BENCH Pension Upgradation 12th January, 2010 both the writ petitions are allowed.(LIC files appeal) The respondent Corporation is directed to take a decision for implementation of the resolution dated 24.11.2001 passed by the Board. The respondent Corporation cannot provide different criteria for grant of dearness allowance to the existing pensioners based on cut off date i.e. 31.7.1997. The benefit arising out of the directions above would, however, be considered by the respondent Corporation so that every retired employee may get the same benefit. Costs made easy. Civil Writ Petition 654(+6676) 2007 Krishna Murari Lal Asthana Union of India & Ors.
3 RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT - JAIPUR BENCH Appeal by LIC of India 21/1/2011 Dismissed LIC to implement Justice Bhandari's decision. SPL. APPL. WRIT 493(+494) 2010 LIFE INSURANCE CORP AND ORS KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA ORS
4 RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT - JAIPUR BENCH Appeal by LIC of India 21/1/2011 Dismissed LIC to implement Justice Bhandari's decision. SPL. APPL. WRIT 494(+493) 2010 LIFE INSURANCE CORP AND ORS KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA ORS
5 RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT - JAIPUR BENCH Revision Petition by LIC of India 19/8/2011 DISPOSED [ DISMISSED ] Previous Judgemet is confirmed. WRIT REVIEW 86 2011 LIFE INSURANCE CORP KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHAN ORS
6 RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT - JAIPUR BENCH Revision Petition by LIC of India 19/8/2011 DISPOSED [ DISMISSED ] Previous Judgemet is confirmed. WRIT REVIEW 87 2011 LIFE INSURANCE CORP KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHAN ORS
7 SUPREME COURT SLP by LIC of India 15/07/2011 DISPOSED Review Petition first SLP 16117(+16118) 2011 LIFE INSURANCE CORP. OF INDIA & ORS. KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA & ORS.
8 SUPREME COURT SLP by LIC of India 15/07/2011 DISPOSED Review Petition first SLP 16118(+16117) 2011 LIFE INSURANCE CORP. OF INDIA & ORS. KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA & ORS.
9 SUPREME COURT SLP by LIC of India Next Date of listing is : 05/10/2012 PENDING SLP 29956 2011 L.I.C. KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA & ORS.
10 SUPREME COURT SLP by LIC of India Next Date of listing is : 05/10/2012 PENDING ` SLP 29957 2011 L.I.C. KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA & ORS.
11 SUPREME COURT Contempt Petition 19/03/2012 DISPOSED petitions are disposed of with liberty in terms of the prayer made. Contempt Petition (Civil) 82(+83) 2012 KRISHAN MURARI LAL ASTHANA L.I.C.OF INDIA & ORS.
12 SUPREME COURT Contempt Petition 19/03/2012 DISPOSED petitions are disposed of with liberty in terms of the prayer made. Contempt Petition (Civil) 83(+82) 2012 KRISHAN MURARI LAL ASTHANA L.I.C.OF INDIA & ORS.
13 SUPREME COURT Contempt Petition JULY 17, 2012. DISPOSED petitions are disposed of with liberty in terms of the prayer made. CPP 124(+125) 2012 Krishna Murari Lal Asthana D.K.MEHROTRA & ORS
14 SUPREME COURT Contempt Petition JULY 17, 2012. DISPOSED petitions are disposed of with liberty in terms of the prayer made. CPP 125(+124) 2012 Krishna Murari Lal Asthana D.K.MEHROTRA & ORS
3.12.11
Pending Court Cases - 03.09.2011
Chart Updated - 30.09.2012.
--------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------
S.No. NEXT DATE OF HEARING (as at 30.09.2012) REGARDING COURT CASE NO. YEAR PETITIONERS RESPONDENTS COURT WEBSITE
1 DISPOSED30/08/2012 - Judgement Awaited upgradation of Pensionb and 100% neutralisation of DR for all pensioners of Banks High Court of Karnataka WRIT PETITION 32475 to 32602 2010 Retd. Bank Officers Confederation ? http://causelist.kar.nic.in/caseStatus_CaseNumber.asp
2 Disposed13/09/2012 - Judgement Awaited Revision of Pay Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 1454 2009 MAHESH CHANDRA JAIN LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
3 6/10/2012 Pay fixation - rectification Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 14446 2010 KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA L I C AND ANR http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
4 10/10/2012 Revision of pension Bombay WRIT PETITIONS (DIVISION BENCH) 2403 2009 All India Reserve Bank Retired Employees Union Reserve Bank Of India &Anr http://bombayhighcourt.nic.in/casequery_action.php
5 25/10/2012 D.R.Anamoly,Revision of Pension. AHMEDABAD SCA-SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION 1507 2007 ALL INDIA RETIRED INSURANCE EMPLOYEES FEDERATION UNION OF INDIA THRO' MINISTRY OF FINANCE http://gujarathc-casestatus.nic.in/gujarathc/tabhome.jsp
6 29/10/2012 Qualifying Service Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 7841 2008 RAMESH CHANDRA KHANDELWAL L I C AND ORS http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
7 30/10/2012 D.R.Anamoly Delhi W.P.(C) 184 2007 FEDERATION OF RETIRED LIC CLAS UOI & ORS. http://delhihighcourt.nic.in/case.asp
8 9-11-2012 Revision of pension Chandigarh CWP 16346 2010 MADAN LAL GANDHI AND ORS UNION OF INDIA AND ORS http://courtnic.nic.in/courtnic_chandigarh/AdvocateDetail.aspx
9 20-Nov-12 Revision of pension etc. Chandigarh CWP 17138 2010 HARCHARAN SINGH VIRDI AND ORS. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS http://courtnic.nic.in/courtnic_chandigarh/AdvocateDetail.aspx
10 26/11/2012 SLP (Civil) SUPREME COURT SLP (Civil) 29956/29957 2011 L.I.C. KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA & ORS. ETC. http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/querycheck.asp
11 29/11/2012 CCP Jaipur Bench CCP 592 2011 KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA RAKESH SINGH AND ANOTHER http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
12 9/1/2013 SERVICE MATTERS - RETIRAL BENEFITS SUPREME COURT Writ Petition (Civil) 184 2011 FEDERATION O SBI PENSIONERS ASS.&ORS. UNION OF INDIA & ORS http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/querycheck.asp
13 ? Nationl.Ins.Vol Retd/Retd.Emp.Asn.& Ors. SUPREME COURT T.C 1096 -1099 2008 Nationl.Ins.Vol Retd/Retd.Emp.Asn.& Ors. ? http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/querycheck.asp
14 ? D.R.Anamoly,Revision of Pension. Allahabad WRIT-A 24580 2007 JAGDISH NARAIN KHANNA AND OTHERS UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS http://www.allahabadhighcourt.in/casestatus/typeG1A.html
15 ? D.R.Anamoly Ernakulam Bench WRIT PETITION (CIVIL 27863 2006 GOPINATHAN & ANOTHER LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION & 2 OTHERS http://courtnic.nic.in/kerala_new/content.asp
16 ? Revision of pension -1.8.1992 Ernakulam Bench WRIT PETITION (CIVIL 6228 2009 C.KRISHNAN LIC OF INDIA http://courtnic.nic.in/kerala_new/content.asp
17 ? Periodic revision of pension Kerala WRIT APPEAL 1903 2010 SBI T.R.VIJAYAN AND OTHERS http://courtnic.nic.in/kerala_new/content.asp
18 ? restoration of commutation Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 2264 2005 A P TIWARI LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION OF http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
19 ? Gold Coin Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 9174 2006 K L MALHOTRA AND ORS LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION AND http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
20 ? THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPAN Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 1908 2007 U.K.PRADHAN AND ORS. THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPAN http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
21 ? CIV. CONTEMPT PET. Jaipur Bench CIV. CONTEMPT PET. 760 2010 RISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA AND T S VIJAYAN AND OTHERS http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
=============================================
1 DISPOSED30/08/2012 - Judgement Awaited upgradation of Pensionb and 100% neutralisation of DR for all pensioners of Banks High Court of Karnataka WRIT PETITION 32475 to 32602 2010 Retd. Bank Officers Confederation ? http://causelist.kar.nic.in/caseStatus_CaseNumber.asp
2 Disposed13/09/2012 - Judgement Awaited Revision of Pay Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 1454 2009 MAHESH CHANDRA JAIN LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
3 6/10/2012 Pay fixation - rectification Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 14446 2010 KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA L I C AND ANR http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
4 10/10/2012 Revision of pension Bombay WRIT PETITIONS (DIVISION BENCH) 2403 2009 All India Reserve Bank Retired Employees Union Reserve Bank Of India &Anr http://bombayhighcourt.nic.in/casequery_action.php
5 25/10/2012 D.R.Anamoly,Revision of Pension. AHMEDABAD SCA-SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION 1507 2007 ALL INDIA RETIRED INSURANCE EMPLOYEES FEDERATION UNION OF INDIA THRO' MINISTRY OF FINANCE http://gujarathc-casestatus.nic.in/gujarathc/tabhome.jsp
6 29/10/2012 Qualifying Service Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 7841 2008 RAMESH CHANDRA KHANDELWAL L I C AND ORS http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
7 30/10/2012 D.R.Anamoly Delhi W.P.(C) 184 2007 FEDERATION OF RETIRED LIC CLAS UOI & ORS. http://delhihighcourt.nic.in/case.asp
8 9-11-2012 Revision of pension Chandigarh CWP 16346 2010 MADAN LAL GANDHI AND ORS UNION OF INDIA AND ORS http://courtnic.nic.in/courtnic_chandigarh/AdvocateDetail.aspx
9 20-Nov-12 Revision of pension etc. Chandigarh CWP 17138 2010 HARCHARAN SINGH VIRDI AND ORS. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS http://courtnic.nic.in/courtnic_chandigarh/AdvocateDetail.aspx
10 26/11/2012 SLP (Civil) SUPREME COURT SLP (Civil) 29956/29957 2011 L.I.C. KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA & ORS. ETC. http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/querycheck.asp
11 29/11/2012 CCP Jaipur Bench CCP 592 2011 KRISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA RAKESH SINGH AND ANOTHER http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
12 9/1/2013 SERVICE MATTERS - RETIRAL BENEFITS SUPREME COURT Writ Petition (Civil) 184 2011 FEDERATION O SBI PENSIONERS ASS.&ORS. UNION OF INDIA & ORS http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/querycheck.asp
13 ? Nationl.Ins.Vol Retd/Retd.Emp.Asn.& Ors. SUPREME COURT T.C 1096 -1099 2008 Nationl.Ins.Vol Retd/Retd.Emp.Asn.& Ors. ? http://courtnic.nic.in/supremecourt/querycheck.asp
14 ? D.R.Anamoly,Revision of Pension. Allahabad WRIT-A 24580 2007 JAGDISH NARAIN KHANNA AND OTHERS UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS http://www.allahabadhighcourt.in/casestatus/typeG1A.html
15 ? D.R.Anamoly Ernakulam Bench WRIT PETITION (CIVIL 27863 2006 GOPINATHAN & ANOTHER LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION & 2 OTHERS http://courtnic.nic.in/kerala_new/content.asp
16 ? Revision of pension -1.8.1992 Ernakulam Bench WRIT PETITION (CIVIL 6228 2009 C.KRISHNAN LIC OF INDIA http://courtnic.nic.in/kerala_new/content.asp
17 ? Periodic revision of pension Kerala WRIT APPEAL 1903 2010 SBI T.R.VIJAYAN AND OTHERS http://courtnic.nic.in/kerala_new/content.asp
18 ? restoration of commutation Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 2264 2005 A P TIWARI LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION OF http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
19 ? Gold Coin Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 9174 2006 K L MALHOTRA AND ORS LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION AND http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
20 ? THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPAN Jaipur Bench CIVIL WRITS 1908 2007 U.K.PRADHAN AND ORS. THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPAN http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
21 ? CIV. CONTEMPT PET. Jaipur Bench CIV. CONTEMPT PET. 760 2010 RISHNA MURARI LAL ASTHANA AND T S VIJAYAN AND OTHERS http://rhccasestatus.raj.nic.in/smsrhcb/rhbcis/index.asp
=============================================
2.12.11
Sri.R.B.KISHORE -Pensioners Emails & Feedback - 12.09.2011
23.10.2012.
--------------
EMAILS & FEEDBACK FROM 1st OCTOBER,2012:SERIES No.39
1)I fondly go through your emails which cover a variety of topics of common interest. I feel that every recipient gets matter of his/her interest in one or the other emails sent by you. For me, reading your emails is as obsessive as reading the daily newspaper or a favorite magazine.
CCC and Pensioners e-mails give clarity to so many subjects as views from different angles on a particular topic are available at a single place. I join the other recipients and beneficiaries of your emails to convey our sincere thanks to you for providing us valuable information and contents through your ‘emails’, ‘CCC’ and ‘pensioner’s emails’. ---M P Agnihotri.
2) RE: 1)THANJAVUR & SALEM VISIT 2)TRUE PICTURE re INTERIM APPLICATION & SLP
Dear Sri Angurajan,
It is neither a formality nor an exaggeration if I say, " YOU HAVE DONE AN EXCELLANT JOB ! " Being in the community welfare activities since 1960, I am fully aware of the difficulties and impediments to be overcome for a single such achievement, whereas yours is an admirable
multiple achievement ! You are, indeed a real marketing man ! My hats off to you for the
wonderful job done ! I shall look forward to an earliest opportunity to meet you in person !
Congratulations ! Keep it up !
With warmest wishes,----A.BALASUBRAMANYA
3) dear mr. kishore, today i have despatched a cheque for rs.2000/ towards legal fund. i pray Almighty to give us favourable decisions in all our cases. long live RIEA.---- S.K.BALAKRISHNAN
4)Thanks and best wishes to Shri Asthana and all.--------Dharmendra Kumar
5)Very very happy to hear that SC has listed the case to hear.
We all thank u for the info.We all pray the Lord to give us the
Victory and solace to the hearts.Pl pass on info after the hearing. --- Raghuraman
6)Thank you very much for forwarding the message on SLP matter.It is true we should ,not only celebrate Navaratri in a be fitting way, pray also Durga Devi. We should invoke the
blessings of Goddess LAKSHMI TO GRACE us with expected benefits
With you for prayer -----R.Srinivasan
7)This LIC’s letter to Joint Secretary, MOF Dt. 31st December 2001, how carefully you managed to secure I do not know and preserved by you so long, is truly a precious and invaluable document, which reveals truth of LIC’s contemplation way back in 2001, in regard to pension upgradation to retirees and 100% DA neutralization to those of pre-August 1997 band. It certainly serves as a categorical, crystal clear and concrete weapon in the armoury of Sri Asthana before the Supreme Court both during Interim Application Submissions as also finally at the time of SLP Hearings and Proceedings. It is, however, unfortunate that such an important communication as this, sadly pertaining to our own pensioners’ matter, lost track of and shelved once and for all in a Government of India undertaking like LIC Corporate Office all these years without making any follow up with MOF and the Government of India itself was silent and remained in such long slumber without any action. It is almost a forgotten chapter at both the ends with the change of guards and generations to the absolute detriment of senior citizens’ community. This should necessarily be brought to the notice of the Supreme Court for the great injustice done to us.
Moreover, the word “prospective effect” used then must be interpreted to be from date 1st day of August 1997 as the cut off date, being the issue itself related to that date prior, and since the proposal and recommendation covers the period for pensioners applicable from 1st day of January 1986 to 31st day of July 1997, as otherwise, inference may be drawn as ‘retrospective effect’ for the respective pensioners retired as from 1st day of January 1986 onwards up to 31st day of July 1997 according to their dates of retirement and to avoid that contingency, guardedly it might have been used as “prospective effect.” It is not to dilly-dally for decades like this and still take advantage of the clause as writing on the wall as “tomorrow,” which will always be ahead and forwards.
This letter seems to be more clarified, more revealing and more strong and effective than the Board Resolution itself as regards the tenor and spirit of the pensioners’ issues at stake and exposes LIC’s fallacy and foul play in twisting facts to their advantage in their Counter Affidavit to the Contempt Petition and SLPs. It is better that we keep this shield in our fold, keep calm for the time being, and shoot at unawares to LIC on the eventful day appropriately, lest should they come to know of it before hand, they may try to make some cover up and give a different sort of build up to protect their skin and come clean about. Accordingly, you discuss with Sri Asthana and plan for projecting and focusing this at the right moment. This may be enjoined with Sri V.R.Krishna Iyer’s letter to former FM Sri Pranab Mukherjee also, which gives further reinforcement of the plea before the SC Judges.
“Truth is the most valuable thing we have. Let us economize it. – Mark Twain
“Truth is a jewel which should not be painted over; but it may be set to advantage and shown in good light.” – George Santayana
I have written whatever that has occurred to my humble mind and conscience tells and I do not know how far it meets with your concurrence. I shall be glad to have your valuable views and comments. Kind regards--------Dr.G.Gopalakrishna
8)IA in SLP 29956 & 29957 /2011 adjourned 17 Oct 2012:
Yes we are praying God , give wisdom to lic managementment.
------Mahesh Kaushik
9)Your superfast communication has no parellel. We wish things unfold favourably at the end. Kindly enlighten me:whether LIC is intending to contact Finance Ministry as to what reply to Court can be given?---K.Venkataraman
10)I am sending to Kishore Sir today a cheque for Rs.1,000 as my Donation for Ahmedabad meeting. Hopefully he will be receiving it within 10-12 days.Thanks and regards Ramanan Madurai,now USA
11)Thank you for your mail on SLP, scheduled for 17th instant. When the petition of Mr Asthana on Court Clarification is likely to be taken up. Wish, you be in good health and spirit.-Dilip Ghosh, Kolkata, LIC Retd Class-I Officers' Association.
12)I AM PENSIONER OF GANDHINAGAR DIVISION, WZ.
I WILL BE HELPFUL IN SENDING YOUR MESSAGES TO MY COLLEAGUE PENSIONER FRIENDS URGENTLY
KINDLY ADD MY E MAIL TO YOUR ADDRESS
pvithalr@gmail.com Regards,VITHALBHAI PATEL
(included, emails select old & now regular done --RBK)
13)I thank you very much for a copy of the beautiful hand book of our Charter of Demands presented to our Chairman by our esteemed Organisation recd. just now. The PROLOGUE compiled by you present a very comprehensive for older peoples demands as per the resolutions of the United Nations and Govt. of India. Most of us may not know about the said resolutions. If the GOI is really interested in their National Policy on Older persons, adopted as far back in Jan 1999, all our justified demands can be accepted by the management without any discussion. But these people have no time to look back and are fully engaged in fighting with Mr. Aravind Kejriwal & party in order to protect their ill gotten wealth running many many crores. God will certainly do justice, I strongly believe. With High respects,-----G. Ramamoorthy
14)Very nice. Thank you very much for the nice portraying of what transpired in the court on 10th October 2012 step by step as if we are physically present and witnessing the court proceedings. It is like a teleprinter message directly received from Asthana at Delhi, similar to what used to happen in LIC offices up to two decades back for passing on communications/promotion orders etc. before computers came into vogue. How difficult it is to ascertain so many details on phone and to convey comprehensively in seriatim without leaving anything that the members generally like to know to their absolute satisfaction! The morale of the members certainly boosts up with your step and action. In granting 1 week's time only against 2 weeks requirement by the LIC counsel, SC displayed great reasonableness and at the same time, gave indication of a message that they are not in favour of such requests anymore and adjourned the case to 17th October 2012.
Yes, we shall remain with prayers for fulfillment of our desires. "The answer to our prayer may be the echo of our resolve." - Lord Samuel.
Kind regards.-----Dr.G.Gopalakrishna
HAPPY NAVRATHRI & DASSARA
15)Thank you very much for your greetings for the ensuing HAPPY NAVARATHRI AND DASSARA and we heartily reciprocate the same to you. May Goddess Durga destroy all evils so far done by the perpetrators and create and bring in fresh light into our lives with the turn of events for undeniable happiness and prosperity by Her majesty, through the corridors of the Supreme Court. "God is the source of light and life and yet He is above and beyond all these." - Gandhi. Thanks & Regards.------Dr.G.Gopalakrishna
16)I join you in greeting the annual arrival of Mother Durga in her infinite variety of power and unbounded grace while praying for victory in our common efforts.--KGopalan
17)I have seen your forwarded message of Tirupathi Darshan along with a fervent appeal for prayer for good things to happen on 17 th oct for the fraternity of retirees
May GOD grace us with bounty of benefits.--------R.Srinivasan
18)Shubha shardiya Abhinandan.----—BinoyKrishna Sen
COLLECTIONS: R.B.KISHORE, VP,AIRIEF 16/10/2012
------------------------------------------------------------------------22.10.2012
-----------
PENSIONERS’ EMAILS & FEEDBACK FROM 16th SEP,2012
--------------
EMAILS & FEEDBACK FROM 1st OCTOBER,2012:SERIES No.39
1)I fondly go through your emails which cover a variety of topics of common interest. I feel that every recipient gets matter of his/her interest in one or the other emails sent by you. For me, reading your emails is as obsessive as reading the daily newspaper or a favorite magazine.
CCC and Pensioners e-mails give clarity to so many subjects as views from different angles on a particular topic are available at a single place. I join the other recipients and beneficiaries of your emails to convey our sincere thanks to you for providing us valuable information and contents through your ‘emails’, ‘CCC’ and ‘pensioner’s emails’. ---M P Agnihotri.
2) RE: 1)THANJAVUR & SALEM VISIT 2)TRUE PICTURE re INTERIM APPLICATION & SLP
Dear Sri Angurajan,
It is neither a formality nor an exaggeration if I say, " YOU HAVE DONE AN EXCELLANT JOB ! " Being in the community welfare activities since 1960, I am fully aware of the difficulties and impediments to be overcome for a single such achievement, whereas yours is an admirable
multiple achievement ! You are, indeed a real marketing man ! My hats off to you for the
wonderful job done ! I shall look forward to an earliest opportunity to meet you in person !
Congratulations ! Keep it up !
With warmest wishes,----A.BALASUBRAMANYA
3) dear mr. kishore, today i have despatched a cheque for rs.2000/ towards legal fund. i pray Almighty to give us favourable decisions in all our cases. long live RIEA.---- S.K.BALAKRISHNAN
4)Thanks and best wishes to Shri Asthana and all.--------Dharmendra Kumar
5)Very very happy to hear that SC has listed the case to hear.
We all thank u for the info.We all pray the Lord to give us the
Victory and solace to the hearts.Pl pass on info after the hearing. --- Raghuraman
6)Thank you very much for forwarding the message on SLP matter.It is true we should ,not only celebrate Navaratri in a be fitting way, pray also Durga Devi. We should invoke the
blessings of Goddess LAKSHMI TO GRACE us with expected benefits
With you for prayer -----R.Srinivasan
7)This LIC’s letter to Joint Secretary, MOF Dt. 31st December 2001, how carefully you managed to secure I do not know and preserved by you so long, is truly a precious and invaluable document, which reveals truth of LIC’s contemplation way back in 2001, in regard to pension upgradation to retirees and 100% DA neutralization to those of pre-August 1997 band. It certainly serves as a categorical, crystal clear and concrete weapon in the armoury of Sri Asthana before the Supreme Court both during Interim Application Submissions as also finally at the time of SLP Hearings and Proceedings. It is, however, unfortunate that such an important communication as this, sadly pertaining to our own pensioners’ matter, lost track of and shelved once and for all in a Government of India undertaking like LIC Corporate Office all these years without making any follow up with MOF and the Government of India itself was silent and remained in such long slumber without any action. It is almost a forgotten chapter at both the ends with the change of guards and generations to the absolute detriment of senior citizens’ community. This should necessarily be brought to the notice of the Supreme Court for the great injustice done to us.
Moreover, the word “prospective effect” used then must be interpreted to be from date 1st day of August 1997 as the cut off date, being the issue itself related to that date prior, and since the proposal and recommendation covers the period for pensioners applicable from 1st day of January 1986 to 31st day of July 1997, as otherwise, inference may be drawn as ‘retrospective effect’ for the respective pensioners retired as from 1st day of January 1986 onwards up to 31st day of July 1997 according to their dates of retirement and to avoid that contingency, guardedly it might have been used as “prospective effect.” It is not to dilly-dally for decades like this and still take advantage of the clause as writing on the wall as “tomorrow,” which will always be ahead and forwards.
This letter seems to be more clarified, more revealing and more strong and effective than the Board Resolution itself as regards the tenor and spirit of the pensioners’ issues at stake and exposes LIC’s fallacy and foul play in twisting facts to their advantage in their Counter Affidavit to the Contempt Petition and SLPs. It is better that we keep this shield in our fold, keep calm for the time being, and shoot at unawares to LIC on the eventful day appropriately, lest should they come to know of it before hand, they may try to make some cover up and give a different sort of build up to protect their skin and come clean about. Accordingly, you discuss with Sri Asthana and plan for projecting and focusing this at the right moment. This may be enjoined with Sri V.R.Krishna Iyer’s letter to former FM Sri Pranab Mukherjee also, which gives further reinforcement of the plea before the SC Judges.
“Truth is the most valuable thing we have. Let us economize it. – Mark Twain
“Truth is a jewel which should not be painted over; but it may be set to advantage and shown in good light.” – George Santayana
I have written whatever that has occurred to my humble mind and conscience tells and I do not know how far it meets with your concurrence. I shall be glad to have your valuable views and comments. Kind regards--------Dr.G.Gopalakrishna
8)IA in SLP 29956 & 29957 /2011 adjourned 17 Oct 2012:
Yes we are praying God , give wisdom to lic managementment.
------Mahesh Kaushik
9)Your superfast communication has no parellel. We wish things unfold favourably at the end. Kindly enlighten me:whether LIC is intending to contact Finance Ministry as to what reply to Court can be given?---K.Venkataraman
10)I am sending to Kishore Sir today a cheque for Rs.1,000 as my Donation for Ahmedabad meeting. Hopefully he will be receiving it within 10-12 days.Thanks and regards Ramanan Madurai,now USA
11)Thank you for your mail on SLP, scheduled for 17th instant. When the petition of Mr Asthana on Court Clarification is likely to be taken up. Wish, you be in good health and spirit.-Dilip Ghosh, Kolkata, LIC Retd Class-I Officers' Association.
12)I AM PENSIONER OF GANDHINAGAR DIVISION, WZ.
I WILL BE HELPFUL IN SENDING YOUR MESSAGES TO MY COLLEAGUE PENSIONER FRIENDS URGENTLY
KINDLY ADD MY E MAIL TO YOUR ADDRESS
pvithalr@gmail.com Regards,VITHALBHAI PATEL
(included, emails select old & now regular done --RBK)
13)I thank you very much for a copy of the beautiful hand book of our Charter of Demands presented to our Chairman by our esteemed Organisation recd. just now. The PROLOGUE compiled by you present a very comprehensive for older peoples demands as per the resolutions of the United Nations and Govt. of India. Most of us may not know about the said resolutions. If the GOI is really interested in their National Policy on Older persons, adopted as far back in Jan 1999, all our justified demands can be accepted by the management without any discussion. But these people have no time to look back and are fully engaged in fighting with Mr. Aravind Kejriwal & party in order to protect their ill gotten wealth running many many crores. God will certainly do justice, I strongly believe. With High respects,-----G. Ramamoorthy
14)Very nice. Thank you very much for the nice portraying of what transpired in the court on 10th October 2012 step by step as if we are physically present and witnessing the court proceedings. It is like a teleprinter message directly received from Asthana at Delhi, similar to what used to happen in LIC offices up to two decades back for passing on communications/promotion orders etc. before computers came into vogue. How difficult it is to ascertain so many details on phone and to convey comprehensively in seriatim without leaving anything that the members generally like to know to their absolute satisfaction! The morale of the members certainly boosts up with your step and action. In granting 1 week's time only against 2 weeks requirement by the LIC counsel, SC displayed great reasonableness and at the same time, gave indication of a message that they are not in favour of such requests anymore and adjourned the case to 17th October 2012.
Yes, we shall remain with prayers for fulfillment of our desires. "The answer to our prayer may be the echo of our resolve." - Lord Samuel.
Kind regards.-----Dr.G.Gopalakrishna
HAPPY NAVRATHRI & DASSARA
15)Thank you very much for your greetings for the ensuing HAPPY NAVARATHRI AND DASSARA and we heartily reciprocate the same to you. May Goddess Durga destroy all evils so far done by the perpetrators and create and bring in fresh light into our lives with the turn of events for undeniable happiness and prosperity by Her majesty, through the corridors of the Supreme Court. "God is the source of light and life and yet He is above and beyond all these." - Gandhi. Thanks & Regards.------Dr.G.Gopalakrishna
16)I join you in greeting the annual arrival of Mother Durga in her infinite variety of power and unbounded grace while praying for victory in our common efforts.--KGopalan
17)I have seen your forwarded message of Tirupathi Darshan along with a fervent appeal for prayer for good things to happen on 17 th oct for the fraternity of retirees
May GOD grace us with bounty of benefits.--------R.Srinivasan
18)Shubha shardiya Abhinandan.----—BinoyKrishna Sen
COLLECTIONS: R.B.KISHORE, VP,AIRIEF 16/10/2012
------------------------------------------------------------------------22.10.2012
-----------
PENSIONERS’ EMAILS & FEEDBACK FROM 16th SEP,2012
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)